Ian Morris (historian)
The core argument of ‘War: What is it Good For?’ is that over the very long term (thousands of years) war has brought about the creation of larger and more organised societies that have been increasingly good at suppressing internal violence, the paradoxical result being that war has progressively decreased the likelihood of people dying violently. Jan 22, · Edwin Starr - War (What Is It Good For?) - YouTube. Edwin Starr - War (What Is It Good For?) If playback doesn't begin shortly, try restarting your device.
Opinion: 'War! What goof it good for? French troops wear an early form of gas mask in the trenches during the 2nd Battle of Ypres in Story highlights SinceU. In ie Stone Age, humans were a rough lot. When people 10, years gooc disagreed, they usually solved their arguments without violence; but when they did decide to use force, they faced far fewer goo than the citizens of functioning modern states. Violence was normally on a small scale, in homicides, vendettas, and raids, but because populations were also tiny, the steady drip of killing took an appalling toll.
If we how to reset e46 airbag light to the 20th century, we see a stunning contrast.
The century suffered world wars, genocides, and nuclear attacks, not to mention us strife, riots, and murders. Altogether, we killed a staggering million of our own kind. Ian Morris. So if you were lucky enough to be born what is 509 a 1 the 20th century, your risk of dying violently was just one-tenth of that in the Stone Age; and sincewar what is it good United Nations tells us, the risk of violent death has fallen even further, to 0.
These are astonishing statistics, but the explanation is more astonishing still. In perhaps the greatest paradox in history, goodd made the world i was war itself. What happened, it seems, is that starting about 10, years ago, the winners of wars began incorporating the losers into larger societies. The victors then found that the only way to make these larger societies work was by developing stronger governments; and one of the first things these governments had to do, if they wanted to stay in power, was suppress violence among their subjects.
More Videos Morris on GPS: War makes peace The men who ran these governments cracked down on killing not because they were saints, but because well-behaved subjects were easier to govern and tax than angry, murderous wae. States that suppressed violence within their borders tended to grow; those that did not, tended to fail. War is surely the worst possible way to create larger, more peaceful societies, but the depressing truth jt that it seems to be pretty much the only way people have found.
If Rome could have been built without killing millions of Gauls and Greeks, or the USA without killing millions of Native Americans -- in these and countless other cases, if conflicts could have been resolved by reason instead of force, the world would have reaped the benefits without paying such costs. But that did not happen. The reality is that people hardly ever give up their freedoms, including their freedom to kill and impoverish each other, unless forced to do so, and virtually the only force strong enough to scare ie straight has been strong government.
Back in the s the philosopher Thomas Hobbes nicknamed this "Leviathan," after the terrifying monster dhat the Old Testament. The process of making Leviathan was not pretty. Whether it was the Romans in Britain or the British in India, dhat could be how to update gdr3 in lumia 520 as bloody as the savagery it stamped out.
Nor were ogod governments equally good Leviathans. Democracies, whatever their other faults, si to how to have love dreams life more than dictatorships. Nor did Leviathan always work the same way. In ancient times, the only way to run large, peaceful societies was by incorporating the conquered into empires, but in the last years, the greatest powers -- Britain in the s, the U.
Nor, finally, was the making of Leviathan smooth. Some wars killed people without creating bigger, safer societies; some even broke such societies down. The 21st-century world does not have a global government enforcing peace, and far from producing such a government, another great-power war could potentially destroy humanity altogether.
The world does, however, have a single great power -- the United States -- capable of acting as a globocop, deterring other governments from using force. The United Nations, European Union, the peace movement, and soft power generally have all done much to make the world a safer place sincebut the lesson of history is clear. At the end of the day, in answer to the song's question -- what has war been good for?
Like it or not, the ultimate guarantee of peace is the order the United States has created.
By its very nature, war produces chaos, but in other eras, particularly for great powers, it has also meant influence or dominance and created the basis for reshaping or controlling whole regions. May 01, · “War! What is it good for?” sings Edwin Starr in his song, before giving an unambiguous answer: “absolutely nothing.” History, archaeology, and .
Ian Matthew Morris born 27 January is a British archaeologist , historian , and academic. From to , he taught at the University of Chicago. Since , he has been at Stanford. He was one of the founders of the Stanford Archaeology Center and has served two terms as its director. He has also won a Dean's Award for Excellence in Teaching in In his work was the subject of a lengthy profile in the Chronicle of Higher Education.
Ian Morris plans to develop his views on the first-millennium BC transformations the shift from religion-based power to bureaucratic and military one, and the rise of Axial thought in his new book. His book, Why the West Rules—For Now , compares East and West across the last 15, years, arguing that physical geography , rather than culture, religion, politics, genetics , or great men , explains Western domination of the globe. The Economist has called it "an important book—one that challenges, stimulates and entertains.
Anyone who does not believe there are lessons to be learned from history should start here. It has been translated into 13 languages. It provides details of the evidence and the statistical methods used by Morris to construct the social development index that he used in Why the West Rules to compare long-term Eastern and Western history.
The International Studies Association and Social Science History Association devoted panels to discussing the book at their annual meetings. The book is being translated into Chinese. What is it Good For? For all of its horrors, over the last 10, years, war has made the world safer and richer, as it is virtually the only way that people have found to create large, internally pacified societies that then drive down the rate of violent death.
The lesson of the last 10, years of military history, he argues, is that the way to end war is by learning to manage it, not by trying to wish it out of existence. Morris also devotes a chapter to the Gombe Chimpanzee War in Tanzania. Five more translations are being prepared. From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia. Ian M. Main article: The Measure of Civilization.
Department of Classics. Stanford University. Ian Matthew, born 27 Jan. Who's Who Oford University Press. Retrieved 17 March E-Thesis Online Service. The British Library Board. Archived from the original on 1 November Retrieved 19 June Archived from the original on 11 December Hoover Institution. Stanford News Service. The Chronicle of Higher Education.
Archived from the original on 5 November The Economist. Archived from the original on 14 July Archived from the original on 19 January Archived from the original PDF on 14 May The Guardian.
Daily Telegraph. What Is It Good For? Wall Street Journal. Namespaces Article Talk. Views Read Edit View history. Help Learn to edit Community portal Recent changes Upload file.
Download as PDF Printable version. University of Birmingham ; Cambridge University. Archaeologist , historian , professor. Why the West Rules—For Now.